Saffron Retail: A Rule Change Is Coming and Nobody Knows How Hard

Strategy
medium45 min0 submissions
McKinsey
Scenario

Saffron Retail operates in apparel retail across India, turning over ₹610 Cr at a 13% operating margin.

A regulator has published draft rules affecting the segment that produces about 65% of revenue. The final text is expected in 30 months.

Two readings are circulating. Under the strict reading, compliance costs roughly ₹19 Cr a year and one product line becomes unsellable in its current form. Under the lenient reading, the cost is largely disclosure and process, perhaps a fifth of that. Trade counsel puts the strict outcome at roughly 46%.

The board wants to know what to do now, before the text is final.

Supporting data

timing

months until final text
30

exposure

revenue cr
610
exposed revenue cr
396.5
exposed revenue pct
65
operating margin pct
13

scenarios

strict
[object Object]
lenient
[object Object]
Your task

Advise the board. Your answer should provide:

  1. Analysis — exposure under each scenario, quantified against revenue and margin.
  2. Risks — including what competitors do, and what waiting costs.
  3. Recommendation — the actions to take now regardless, and the trigger for the rest.

State any assumptions you make.

Ready to move forward? Up next: Kirana Connect: Buy the Supplier or Keep Buying From Them?Next question
How you'll be graded

80 points, 60% to pass.

  • recommendation10
  • market analysis25
  • risk assessment25
  • financial analysis20
Hint
Reveal suggested structure

Build two discrete scenarios, quantify exposure in each, separate no-regrets moves from contingent ones, and price the option value of waiting.